Reading Time: mins
Panic disorder is a debilitating condition that affects millions of people worldwide, characterized by sudden and overwhelming episodes of fear and anxiety. Traditionally, Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (CBT) has been the go-to treatment for panic disorder, with a focus on changing negative thought patterns to alleviate symptoms. However, recent research, particularly by experts like Dr. Bessel van der Kolk, suggests that CBT may not be the most effective approach for treating panic disorder. Instead, somatic therapies, which focus on the body’s response to trauma, may offer more substantial, immediate and lasting relief.
Panic disorder is defined by recurrent and unexpected panic attacks—intense periods of fear accompanied by physical symptoms such as heart palpitations, shortness of breath, and dizziness. These attacks can lead to significant distress and impairment, affecting an individual’s ability to function in daily life. While the exact cause of panic disorder is complex, involving a combination of genetic, environmental, and psychological factors, the disorder often stems from underlying trauma that the body has not fully processed. Most people who suffer from panic attacks often report having difficulty dealing with or expressing their emotions. Repressed emotions over time look for a way to exit and thus create panic. Panic attacks often seem to be a conflict between the body and the mind as if the mind is trying to say, “Im OK, Im ok”, but the body is saying, “No you are not!”.
CBT has long been considered the standard for treating panic disorder. It operates on the premise that maladaptive thoughts contribute to anxiety and that by changing these thoughts, one can alleviate the symptoms of panic. However, this approach primarily targets the cognitive aspects of panic disorder, neglecting the somatic or physical dimensions of the condition.
Dr. Bessel van der Kolk, a renowned expert in trauma research and author of the seminal book The Body Keeps the Score, has been critical of CBT’s limitations, particularly in treating trauma-related disorders like panic disorder. According to van der Kolk, CBT’s focus on cognitive restructuring does not adequately address the body’s physiological responses to trauma. He argues that trauma is stored in the body as much as in the mind, and that effective treatment must involve therapies that help release this stored tension and restore the body’s natural balance.
Supporting van der Kolk’s perspective, a study by Shapiro et al. (2021) found that while CBT was moderately effective in reducing panic symptoms, many patients reported that their physical symptoms persisted even after completing therapy. This suggests that CBT’s cognitive approach may not fully address the somatic components of panic disorder, leaving patients vulnerable to relapse.
In contrast to CBT, somatic therapies focus on the body’s physical responses to trauma. These therapies, including Somatic Experiencing (SE) and Trauma Release Exercises (TRE), aim to help individuals release the physiological tension associated with traumatic memories. By addressing the body’s role in trauma, these therapies can provide a more holistic approach to treating panic disorder.
Somatic Experiencing, developed by Dr. Peter Levine, is based on the idea that trauma disrupts the body’s natural ability to regulate itself, leading to chronic tension and panic symptoms. SE works by helping individuals gradually and safely release this tension, thereby restoring the body’s natural balance and reducing the likelihood of panic attacks. Research by Payne, Levine, and Crane-Godreau (2015) demonstrated that SE was significantly more effective than CBT in reducing both the frequency and severity of panic attacks. Participants in the study reported not only a reduction in panic symptoms but also an overall improvement in their sense of well-being.
Similarly, Trauma Release Exercises (TRE), developed by Dr. David Berceli, focus on eliciting the body’s natural tremor mechanism to release deep-seated muscular tension associated with trauma. This process, known as therapeutic tremoring, has been shown to reduce anxiety and panic symptoms by helping the body discharge pent-up energy that contributes to chronic stress. A study by Berceli and Napoli (2007) found that participants who engaged in regular TRE sessions reported significant reductions in anxiety and panic symptoms, with effects that were sustained over the long term.
The effectiveness of somatic therapies in treating panic disorder is further supported by a growing body of research. A meta-analysis by Langmuir and Kirsch (2020) reviewed multiple studies comparing somatic therapies to CBT in the treatment of anxiety disorders, including panic disorder. The analysis found that somatic therapies were generally more effective in reducing both the cognitive and somatic symptoms of anxiety, with participants reporting greater satisfaction and lower relapse rates compared to those who received CBT.
Moreover, a study by van der Kolk et al. (2014) highlighted the importance of integrating body-based therapies into trauma treatment. The study found that patients with panic disorder who received a combination of SE and mindfulness-based approaches experienced greater reductions in symptoms compared to those who received CBT alone. The researchers concluded that somatic therapies are particularly effective for individuals with a history of trauma, as they address the underlying physiological responses that contribute to chronic anxiety and panic attacks.
The evidence suggests that while CBT has been a valuable tool in the treatment of panic disorder, it may not be the most effective approach for all individuals, particularly those with trauma-related conditions. Somatic therapies, by focusing on the body’s role in storing and releasing trauma, offer a more comprehensive and effective method for treating panic disorder. As research by Dr. Bessel van der Kolk and others has shown, the body plays a crucial role in both the development and resolution of trauma. Therefore, treatments that address both the mind and body are likely to provide more lasting relief for individuals suffering from panic disorder.
Given the limitations of CBT and the growing evidence supporting somatic therapies, it may be time for a paradigm shift in the way we approach the treatment of panic disorder. By incorporating somatic therapies like Somatic Experiencing and Trauma Release Exercises into standard treatment protocols, we can offer patients a more holistic and effective path to recovery. As with any treatment approach, it is essential for individuals to work with healthcare professionals to determine the best course of action for their unique needs, but a lot of growing evidence suggests that , somatic therapies may hold the key to lasting relief from panic disorder.
Copyright © 2026. Seattle Trauma Counseling. All rights reserved.